New Amsterdam: Striking a Balance Between Noble Intentions and Viewer Fatigue

When I started watching New Amsterdam, it was a good surprise among all the medical shows on TV. It was slightly different and good entertainment. Yet, in Season 3, it feels a little too much.

Sure, most shows tend to become repetitive after a few seasons, but here, that's not exactly the issue.

A Sweet but Unbelievable Character

New Amsterdam's Dr. Max Goodwin is shown as the megalomaniac boss with a heart of gold. He has decided to solve all the world's problems, but usually things go sideways. Initially endearing, his actions eventually affect the show's credibility. Who in the real world would act like this, brushing aside practicality and realism?

As the character takes bigger and bigger challenges as banners, the balance between a relatable protagonist and an idealistic savior is lost.

Every Issue Becomes a Crisis

New Amsterdam doesn't shy away from addressing moral dilemmas, but the sheer volume of dramatic situations can be overwhelming.

Every episode seems to present a new moral issue. Then, the characters engage in exhaustive overthinking, which makes it hard to connect with. While addressing important societal topics is a plus, the show risks losing its audience due to the relentless stream of moral challenges, leaving little room for viewers to breathe.

A Never-Ending Cycle of Unrealistic Chaos

New Amsterdam is the constant barrage of apocalyptic-scale disasters within the hospital. From pandemic scares to catastrophic accidents, chaos is everywhere. It feels more like a Hollywood blockbuster than a portrayal of a realistic healthcare environment.

The lack of more minor, more believable challenges undermines the show. Yes, real-life hospitals face numerous challenges, but the exaggerated scale of disasters in New Amsterdam goes way too far.

Balancing Drama and Realism

While New Amsterdam initially captivates with its noble intentions and compelling characters, the show's tendency to veer into melodramatic and unrealistic scenarios makes it tiring to watch.

Striking a balance between engaging storytelling and maintaining a sense of authenticity has been a challenge.

Comments

Conversations with a Killer: The Ted Bundy Tapes

This is not the sort of show which I usually talk about on this blog. However, as a psychologist, I’m usually quite curious in regards to criminals and their minds; and one of these days I started watching this documentary on Netflix . Taking into consideration the kind of thing this is, I can’t say I ‘liked’ it. I mean what you see in there is nothing to like, but I was rather terrified, which is probably the usual response. Nonetheless, it was definitely a good documentary. The eyes of a killer Everything displayed in this story was terrible. The descriptions, Bundy’s posture, everything seemed like some sort of horror show, putting into perspective what we may consider to be lucky or unlucky in this life. Before I even start watching it, I read somewhere that this was the kind of thing you shouldn’t watch alone. Sounds accurate right now. At the time, and considering my, mostly academic, experience, I didn’t think that this could actually be so upsetting. ...

Young Sheldon – A Heartfelt and Hilarious Journey

Young Sheldon is a delightful surprise, blending humor, heart, and a touch of nostalgia. As a prequel to The Big Bang Theory , the show offers insight into the childhood of Sheldon Cooper, one of the most iconic characters in modern TV. A Show That Grows Beyond Sheldon While you may start watching due to curiosity about Sheldon's early years, it soon becomes clear that this is not just about his childhood. The show includes an incredible variety of characters with their own charm and depth. Mary (Sheldon's religious yet compassionate mother), George (his often misunderstood father), and his siblings, Missy and Georgie, are all given their own moments to shine. The cast and their chemistry make this show stand out. You start to care about each character's struggles and triumphs. This show quickly stands on its own as a heartfelt, family-driven sitcom. Especially in its last seasons, the show becomes a touching portrayal of small-town life, family dynamics, and persona...

House of the Dragon: Season 2 - a Matter of Good Characters

As a fan of the original Game of Thrones , I approached the second season of House of the Dragon with high hopes. Unfortunately, I found it a bit boring compared to its predecessor. The intricate political drama and the rich character development that made Game of Thrones a global phenomenon seem to be lacking here. Still, the show features some compelling characters who hold my interest. Daemon Targaryen Daemon Targaryen remains one of the most intriguing characters in the series. Although his arc in this season isn't as strong as before, he still commands the screen with his charisma and unpredictability. Daemon's complex personality, oscillating between villainy and heroism, keeps viewers guessing his true intentions. His relationship with Rhaenyra and his struggle for power add depth to his character. He is, no doubt, a central figure in the unfolding drama. Aemond Targaryen Aemond steps into the spotlight in the second season, bringing a new level of intensity ...

All Forms of Art

Search This Blog