I started watching Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart because I knew it had a happy ending. I thought that knowing Elizabeth was found alive would make the story easier to bear — even hopeful. In a world where so many kidnapping cases end in tragedy, this felt like a reminder that sometimes children do come back.
But that sense of comfort didn’t last long.
Instead of hope, the documentary left me deeply disturbed, sad, and honestly paranoid. I watched it at night, and afterward all I wanted to do was go into my kids’ rooms, pick them up, and bring them into bed with me. It’s the kind of documentary that crawls under your skin and stays there.
A Family’s Living Nightmare
One of the most unbearable aspects of this story is imagining the pain Elizabeth’s family endured. How do you continue with daily life when you don’t know where your daughter is? If she’s alive. If she’s being hurt. If she’s cold, hungry, scared.
Your mind must be a nonstop horror movie, running through endless scenarios. The waiting. The not knowing. The constant fear. It’s absolutely terrifying, and the documentary does a powerful job of making you feel the weight of that suffering.
A Small Hero in an Impossible Situation
Elizabeth’s sister deserves special recognition. She was just a child herself, placed in an impossible and traumatic position — yet she helped save her sister.
That kind of bravery, especially at such a young age, is remarkable. She didn’t just survive that moment; she made a difference. Calling her a little hero doesn’t feel exaggerated at all.
Elizabeth’s Pain, Shame, and Unfair Self-Blame
The suffering Elizabeth endured is heartbreaking. She was so young, so naïve, and completely powerless. Listening to her talk about the confusion, the fear, and especially the shame is devastating.
What hurts most is hearing her internal thoughts — the “I should have done this” or “I should have done that” — as if she bore any responsibility at all.
Those moments make you want to reach through the screen and hug her, just to reassure her that none of this was her fault. That she survived something unimaginable. That she was a child facing pure evil.
Monsters, Justice, and Uncontrolled Rage
The final part of the documentary brings some relief. The monster is in prison — though I honestly believe 15 years for the wife is nowhere near enough. She was just as complicit, just as cruel. It wasn't his crime; it was their crime. Just as in the Rose and Fred West case, they are equally responsible.
The interrogation scenes are infuriating. Everything about him — his posture, his attitude, his words — makes you mad. Watching the police maintain professionalism is impressive because I know I couldn’t have done it.
I’ll be honest: I would have ended up in jail too. Not just because of what he did, but because of how he behaved afterward. The lack of remorse. The arrogance. The sheer inhumanity.
What's in the Dark?
Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart is a good documentary — but “good” doesn’t mean easy or comforting. It’s disturbing, emotional, and deeply unsettling. It forces you to confront the darkest parts of humanity while also witnessing incredible resilience and courage.
This is not a feel-good watch, even with a happy ending. It’s a reminder of how fragile safety can be, how strong survivors are, and how vigilant we feel afterward — especially as parents.
Watch it, but be prepared.
Comments
Post a Comment