The Boys: Season 5, Epi 5 - A Strange Calm Before the Storm

 

After the stumble that was Episode 4, The Boys bounces back with an episode that feels refreshingly different. It’s lighter, funnier, and—surprisingly—more introspective. While it may not push the main plot forward in a major way, it delivers something arguably just as valuable: character. 

A Quieter Episode That Actually Works

This isn’t an action-heavy episode, and that’s exactly why it succeeds.

Instead of constant chaos, we get something rarer in this show—stillness. Watching the team simply exist, without a mission breathing down their necks, adds texture to characters we usually see under pressure. The highlight here is Terror’s POV, which is both hilarious and oddly charming.

And then there’s Billy Butcher (Karl Urban). When he’s not consumed by rage or revenge, he becomes almost… human. His softer moments with Terror are unexpectedly sweet, offering a glimpse of who he might have been under different circumstances. It’s a subtle but important reminder: Butcher isn’t just a weapon—he’s a person.

Kimiko: A Frustrating Decline

Not every character benefits from this shift in tone.

Kimiko (Karen Fukuhara) remains one of the most disappointing aspects of the season. The writing leans into making her feel more irritating than compelling, and it’s unclear why. 

There’s a difference between flawed and frustrating—and right now, she’s drifting too far into the latter.

Soldier Boy & Homelander: Twisted Family Dynamics

The evolving dynamic between Soldier Boy (Jensen Ackles) and Homelander remains one of the most entertaining threads.

There’s something darkly comedic about Soldier Boy trying—trying—to bond with someone as unstable as Homelander (Antony Starr). What’s interesting is that he isn’t shocked by Homelander’s behavior. Surprised, yes. Concerned, maybe. But never truly shocked. That says a lot about the kind of man Soldier Boy is.

And yet, there are hints of something softer emerging. He calls Homelander a “weirdo,” but there’s a growing sense that he might actually be developing a strange, reluctant attachment. Not quite affection—but something close enough to matter.

The Supernatural Reunion Steals the Show

Let’s be honest—this was the standout moment.

Seeing Jared Padalecki and Misha Collins show up is already fun, but the way the episode uses them makes it even better. Misha’s brief appearance is memorable thanks to a power that’s equal parts absurd and hilarious.

But Jared, as “Mr. Marathon,” is the real highlight. The callback to Season 1, combined with Soldier Boy making him accidentally kill his friends, is classic The Boys—dark, ironic, and funny in a deeply uncomfortable way.

There’s also something slightly off about the interaction—and in a good, intriguing way. Mr. Marathon clearly knew Homelander, which makes his behavior a bit… questionable. He’s surprisingly relaxed, almost too comfortable speaking openly. Was he assuming Soldier Boy was there to protect him? Or was he just underestimating the danger?

Because here’s the thing: he should know better. Homelander’s super-hearing isn’t exactly a secret. Speaking that freely, in that moment, feels either reckless or desperate.

And maybe that’s the point.

It subtly reinforces how people around Homelander operate—constantly aware of the threat, but never fully able to process it. They talk too much, push too far, or convince themselves they’re safe… right until they aren’t.

More importantly, his interaction with Soldier Boy gives us a key moment: you can see the shift. That’s when it clicks—Soldier Boy is starting to feel something about having a son. He may not understand it, but it’s there.

Firecracker, Starlight, and Moral Gray Areas

At first, the subplot involving Firecracker (Valorie Curry) feels unnecessary. But by the end, its purpose becomes clearer.

Her presence adds another layer to Homelander’s already fragile psyche—and while he doesn’t need much to snap, every push counts.

What’s more interesting is how her past reframes things. It brings back what Starlight (Erin Moriarty) did to her (watch Season 4), raising an uncomfortable question: Is Firecracker actually the worst person here, or just the more desperate one?

Her actions now may be misguided, driven by survival instinct around Homelander—but there’s something tragic in her arc. Her death lands harder than expected, especially because she could have been a valuable addition to the Boys’ side.

Sister Sage & Ashley: A Game Within the Game

Sister Sage (Susan Heyward) is too smart to make careless mistakes. Which is why her apparent openness with Ashley (Colby Minifie) feels… off.

Even if she was drunk, it’s hard to believe she’d reveal anything important without a deeper plan in motion. There has to be more here.

Meanwhile, Ashley continues to evolve in interesting ways. Season after season, she’s grown from comic relief into something far more complex. If she ends up being the one to take down Homelander, it would be the ultimate twist—the kind of narrative reversal that The Boys thrives on.

The Deep, Noir, and the Line Being Crossed

Then there’s The Deep (Chace Crawford).

That… fish scene. Wild, disturbing, and undeniably The Boys.

But beyond the shock value, it raises a real question: has The Deep crossed a line? He’s always been pathetic—selfish, insecure, desperate for approval—but not truly monstrous. This moment suggests a shift. Something darker. Something more intentional.

Could he actually be evolving into a real threat?

On the other side, the new Black Noir (Nathan Mitchell) remains oddly endearing. He feels completely out of place among these monsters, which somehow makes him more likable.

A Detour Worth Taking

Yes, the main plot barely moves forward. The search for V1 continues, but without major developments.

And yet—it doesn’t matter.

This episode works because it leans into tone, character, and absurdity. It’s funny, disturbing, and unexpectedly reflective. A reminder that The Boys doesn’t always need to escalate to stay engaging.

Sometimes, slowing down is exactly what it needs.